Hollywood Starlet Carole Lombard Met Her End Thanks To An Ill-Fated Coin Toss

Classic Hollywood star Carole Lombard dazzled audiences with her beauty and made them laugh with her impeccable timing. But more than that, she was a patriot, an independent woman, and a loving wife. That was why her shocking death at the age of 33 left the world devastated. Yet her whirlwind career might not have been cut tragically short had she not won a fatal coin toss.

A tragic end to a bright star

Carole Lombard died on January 16, 1942, in a plane crash on the outskirts of Las Vegas. She had been helping with the war effort at the time, and the news of her death left Hollywood in a state of shock.

“Carole Lombard gave her life in the service of America,” Will Hays, president of Motion Picture Producers and Distributors of America, told Variety at the time. Variety described her as "the first casualty of show business in this world war."

She was quick to join the war effort

The U.S. entered the war at the end of 1941, after the attack on Pearl Harbor. Before this time, though, Lombard and her incredibly famous husband, Clark Gable, were outspoken in their backing of President Franklin D. Roosevelt.

So it made sense that when the U.S. Treasury encouraged movie stars and the Hollywood elite to try to sell war bonds, Lombard was one of the first to respond. Lombard and Hays started their bond tour — the first of its kind in the U.S. — on January 15, 1942, in Indianapolis

She was a massive success

Indianapolis proved to be the perfect place for Lombard to start her tour of duty. She was originally from Fort Wayne, and her home state was no doubt proud of her for achieving a life of fame and fortune. They certainly responded to her rally.

The Treasury Department set a target of $500,000 in war bonds and stamps for this rally. But after Lombard appeared at the Statehouse and the Cadle Tabernacle, she pushed residents to smash that target four times over.

"Carole was perfect"

Will Hays was particularly pleased with Lombard's performance. “Great day here today," Hays wrote in a wire to Gable. "Carole was perfect. Really, she was magnificent and they sold in this one day $2,017,513 worth of bonds."

“Everyone deeply grateful I feel I must send you this expression of my personal appreciation,” Hays ended. Lombard had gone to Indianapolis with her mother, Elizabeth Peters, and MGM publicist Otto Winkler.

She never made it home

After their work was done, Lombard, Peters, Winkler, and a number of other passengers boarded a commercial TWA flight bound for Los Angeles. It took off without incident and landed in Albuquerque sometime around 4:00 a.m. on January 16, 1942.

Four unknowingly lucky people got off the plane at that point and 15 pilots and enlisted men from the Army Air Corp. boarded. The flight made it without any problems to Las Vegas — but that was as far as Lombard and the other passengers got.

It was an avoidable tragedy

Clark Gable was already at Burbank airport when he heard news of the crash. He immediately got on a plane and flew to Las Vegas — but there was little he could do by the time he got there.

Tributes poured in from every corner of Hollywood. But what the public would only find out later was that Lombard was never supposed to be on that plane in the first place.

An unthinkable accident

The TWA flight took off from Las Vegas with the intention of reaching Burbank sometime later. But 50 miles southwest of Las Vegas, the aircraft struck Mt. Potosi in Nevada. The plane was obliterated and its wreckage scattered over the landscape.

The fact that the plane crashed in such a mountainous location in winter made it difficult for rescuers to get to the scene. The nature of the crash also meant the 22 victims would not be easily identifiable.

She was a beloved star

This was despite Lombard being a face known around America. Part of the reason she had captured the hearts of a nation was her fairytale Hollywood story. After all, she had come a long way since being born as Jane Peters in Fort Wayne.

After moving to Hollywood, a 12-year-old Lombard was spotted by film director Allan Dwan. He described her as "a cute-looking little tomboy... out there knocking the hell out of the other kids, playing better baseball than they were." He decided to cast her in his next picture.

Things happened fast

Dwan gave Lombard a small part in his silent 1921 movie, A Perfect Crime. It was hardly a massive success, but Dwan later claimed that Lombard "ate up" her two days on the production.

Lombard returned to her education at Fairfax High School, but it wasn't long before she left school for the movies. At 16, she signed a contract with Fox and changed her name. That's when things started to happen for her.

She escaped death early on

Lombard was not exactly impressed with her early roles. "All I had to do was simper prettily at the hero and scream with terror when he battled with the villain," she once said. But in 1925 she turned heads with a rare leading role.

One reviewer wrote that Lombard had "good poise and considerable charm" in Marriage in Transit. But just as her career looked like it was going to take off, an accident threatened to put an end to it.

A scarring accident

Lombard was coming up in the world as a “bathing beauty” in short films produced by Mack Sennett. But then she went on a date with a man named Harry Cooper — and they crashed into another car.

Shards of glass left Lombard with a scar all across her left cheek. She later claimed in a lawsuit against Cooper that "where she formerly was able to earn a salary of $300 monthly as a Sennett girl, she is now unable to obtain employment of any kind."

Her big break was right around the corner

Luckily, Sennett promised her he'd get her career big on track — and he did exactly that. He named her "Carole of the Curves" and put as much publicity behind her as possible. The strategy worked.

Historian Olympia Kiriakou explained, "The nickname simultaneously drew audiences' focus away from her facial scars and worked harmoniously with the physicality and female sensuality that were emblematic of Lombard's performances." Lombard later called her time with Sennett "the turning point of [her] acting career."

Her first marriage was almost as starry as her second

In 1931 Lombard starred in the films Man of the World and Ladies Man with William Powell, who was a big star for Paramount. She had admired Powell from afar before they started working together — and then the pair developed an intimate off-screen relationship.

On paper, the union shouldn't have worked. Lombard was 16 years younger than Powell and considerably more easygoing and crass. But Lombard said they shared a "love between two people who are diametrically different" and that it was a "perfect see-saw love." They married in June 1931... for two years and two months.

A new man on the scene

In 1936 Lombard said that their careers "had little to do with the divorce." Instead, she revealed, "We were just two completely incompatible people." She made her one and only film with Clark Gable, No Man of Her Own, in 1932.

But there were no sparks behind the camera at that point. The pair reunited a few years later, and, after much press speculation and Gable's eventual separation from his wife, Lombard and Gable wed in 1939. They remained together until her tragic death.

They were a golden couple — but they weren't perfect

Gable and Lombard were the power couple of the age, and they were devoted to each other. They bought a ranch together and started referring to each other as Ma and Pa. But this devotion didn't stop Gable from straying.

According to Lombard's biographers, Lombard told herself that it was okay for Gable to cheat because he was "the King of Hollywood." But that didn't mean she liked it — particularly when it came to Lana Turner.

The problem with Lana Turner

Gable and Turner made four movies together, and they were rumored to have been very close. Turner even claimed that she had “a wonderful chemical rapport” with her frequent co-star, and that was enough of a red flag for Lombard.

In Fireball: Carole Lombard and the Mystery of Flight 3 by Robert Matzen, the author claimed that Lombard was on the set of Gable and Turner's Honky Tonk that Turner once had to retire to her trailer. And Turner was also apparently a much-discussed topic around Lombard's death.

A fight over Gable's extramarital activities

In Warren G. Harris’s 1974 biography, Gable & Lombard, Harris claimed that Lombard and Gable had a blazing row on January 12, 1942 — a few days before her death. The problem? Lombard had had enough of Gable's wandering eye.

They still weren't talking when Lombard left for Indianapolis. Harris said Gable didn't see her off at the train station — and that Lombard left a naked mannequin in their bed as a joke. It probably didn't help that Gable was filming Somewhere I’ll Find You with Lana Turner at the time.

Gable wasn't getting involved

Harris also claimed in his book that Gable only got involved in the Hollywood Victory Committee to get Lombard off his back. She was apparently the one who was most obsessed with wanting to do something to help with the war.

Harris also claimed that the idea of using Lombard to sell war bonds first came to Gable — and that he refused to join her even after she implored him. So, the biographer argued, Lombard had other things on her mind when she boarded that plane home to Gable.

Lombard wanted to get back to Gable

Author Matzen told Time, "At the end of January 15, 1942, [Lombard] decided she had done her duty — and now it was time to take care of Carole Lombard by getting home to her carousing husband by the fastest means possible."

"That meant air travel," he continued, "something expressly forbidden because of the fear of accidents in wintry weather or sabotage by Hitler’s spies." It seems Lombard's mother also didn't want to take the plane.

Too tired for the train

Matzen also said in his book that Lombard was desperate to get back before dark. But in a Life article published right after her death, the magazine said she'd told them she just couldn't face three days on "the choo-choo train."

This was despite being "strongly urged" to get the train home, as planned. But, the actor said, she was too tired. "When I get home," Lombard told Life, "I'll flop in bed and sleep for 12 hours."

Lombard's mother had a bad feeling

Lombard's mother was a believer in the Bahāʾīs religion and a follower of numerology. Matzen claimed that Elizabeth didn't want to get that train because she saw signs that something bad would happen.

She apparently even warned her daughter" “Carole, don’t take that plane.” Winkler — the other member of Lombard's party — was also dubious about the plane. So Lombard reportedly proposed they settle the argument with a coin toss.

The fateful coin toss

Lombard won, and it proved to be a fateful decision. “She died for her country,” the Treasury Department said in its tribute. President Roosevelt paid his respects to Lombard with a statement, too.

“Mrs. Roosevelt and I are deeply distressed," he said. “Carole was our friend and guest in happier days. She brought great joy to all who knew her and to the millions who knew her only as a great artist.”

Gable was never the same again

Lombard and her mother were burned in a joint funeral on January 21, 1942. Gable turned down the government's offer of a military funeral because it didn't fit with Lombard's view of herself in the world. But Gable was never the same again.

He took to drinking pretty heavily after Lombard's death. "The most wonderful and the most beautiful and the greatest thing — the only real happiness he ever had in his life — was gone," MGM head of publicity Howard Strickling said.

Gable never got over it

Vanity Fair reported that Gable once told his secretary, “You know, I have everything in the world anyone could want but one thing. All I really need and want is Ma.” But he did turn his life around.

According to Matzen, he joined the army in honor of Lombard's wishes and became a more sensitive person. Orson Welles once called Gable “a nice big hunk of man.” But this drastic career change went against the wishes of his studio and even the president himself.

Behind-the-scenes tragedy

Clark Gable left an impressive legacy in Hollywood, but his personal life is another story entirely. Sadly, the generations who came after him have suffered terrible difficulties.

His grandson – who happened to look a lot like the actor and even shared his name – passed away in February 2019. And when that tragic event happened, it reopened some old wounds.

Born into an iconic family

The legendary actor’s late grandson was Clark Gable III – the son of John Clark Gable and Tracy Yarro Scheff. Unsurprisingly, he grew up right in the middle of the entertainment world.

Clark III’s stepfather was Jason Scheff, who was the one-time bassist for the band Chicago. And both his father and sister Kayley dabbled in acting.

Never knew dad

Though Clark III knew his father, John Clark Gable never did. The first famous Gable passed away in 1960, just four months before his son was born to his fifth wife Kay.

He had delighted in the prospect of the baby’s arrival and even helped create a beautiful yellow nursery for him. Furthermore, he told People that his plan was to be a dedicated hands-on father.

A sudden tragedy

But fate, unfortunately, had other plans. On November 6, 1960, Clark had a heart attack and was kept in hospital for several days. The newspapers reported that he was improving.

But on November 16 he suffered an arterial blood clot and died at the age of just 59. John Clarke Gable would be born in that same hospital four months later.

Kay's decision

When arrangements were made for the funeral, it was decided that Clark would be buried next to his deceased third wife: Carole Lombard.

She had been killed in a plane crash in 1942, and according to the newspapers of the time, it was Kay’s decision to have that location as Clark’s resting place.

The one true love

Although of course Clark had been married many times, it was rumored that Carole had been the real love of his life. When they first met, the actor was still officially married to his second wife Maria “Rhea” Langham.

However, they were separated. And their respective studios were furious when Carole and Clark began going out in public together.

Get the studio to pay

In an attempt to avoid scandal, Clark requested an official divorce from Maria. She agreed, but only if her estranged husband paid her off. The star subsequently asked his bosses at MGM for the money.

They gave it to him in exchange for his involvement in Gone with the Wind. Then, a mere 21 days after the divorce went through, Clark and Carole married. That didn't make him the most faithful husband, though.

Baby Judy

If Clark had indeed learned the value of fidelity earlier, his love child Judy Lewis might never have been born. The latter was the half-sister of John Clark Gable and thus the half-aunt of the late Clark Gable III.

And she didn’t know the truth of her parentage until she was a grown adult herself. It came as quite a shock, as you would expect.

An impossible romance

Judy’s mother was the famous actress Loretta Young, and the latter had met Gable while the two were filming the 1935 movie The Call of the Wild.

He was married to his second wife at that point, and Loretta, meanwhile, was a devoted Catholic. Therefore, a pregnancy out of wedlock would have been a devastating scandal.

Excuses

Loretta and her family worked fast to hide the pregnancy. If news got out to her studio that she was pregnant, they would insist that she had a quiet abortion, but Loretta’s religious beliefs put her firmly against that.

Rumors began spreading in the media and in showbiz circles that the actress was “fatigued,” but of course that wasn’t quite the truth.

Hiding the pregnancy

When a reporter dropped into Loretta’s home to see her, the actress spoke from her bed with pillows that were carefully placed to conceal the pregnancy.

And as the due date grew ever closer, her family reportedly soundproofed the house with blankets so that no one would hear any screaming and get suspicious.

"Father: Blank"

As soon as the baby arrived, a telegram was sent to Clark informing him of the news. Reportedly, however, he took a look and ripped it up.

Loretta named the baby Judy after St Jude – the patron saint of both lost causes and hope. And when it came time to fill out the birth certificate, she apparently left the space for “father” blank.

Rushing to come to an explanation

Fearing blackmail, the family decided to spin a story about Loretta adopting some children. First, little Judy would spend a short time in an orphanage – despite her parents being very much alive.

Then, Loretta would claim her while at the same time telling the press that she’d adopted two girls. One, of course, was fictional, and soon, according to Buzzfeed News, “a relative” would “claim her back.”

An indistinguishable trait

That left Loretta with one child – her biological one. But she was still worried that rumors might start swirling as Judy grew older. The child had the same ears as her father too.

Such was Loretta’s fear that the secret might be exposed, she reportedly took her then-seven-year-old daughter to a surgeon to have them pinned back.

Tragedy strikes

In 1949, the same year Clark married his fourth wife, Sylvia Ashley, Loretta agreed to star in Keys to the City with the secret father of her child. The actress had married at this point to a man called Tom Lewis.

She’d had two more children plus a surname to give to her secret one. But on the set of the film, she collapsed and Clark had to carry her out. Then 15 days later, she miscarried a pregnancy.

Spinning P.R.

During the publicity tour for Keys to the City, Loretta went out of her way to announce that she had barely seen Clark in the past few years. The truth, of course, was much more complicated.

The premiere party was held at her home and Gable was there. He briefly met his daughter, who of course had no clue who he was.

Finding out the truth

Eventually, as Judy grew older, the truth began to unravel. At 23 years old she became engaged to a man called Joseph Tinney, who told her that Clark was her father.

It took several years, but Judy eventually confronted her mother with this knowledge. A very difficult conversation then revealed exactly who her parents really were.

The memoir comes out

In 1994, long after Clark’s death, Judy published a memoir about her experiences: Uncommon Knowledge. It began with the words, “My life has been filled with hypocrisy and deception from the moment I was born.”

Loretta and her daughter were estranged at that point, and they would only make up a short time before the former’s death in 2000.

Memories caught on film

In 2002 Judy gave an interview to The Telegraph in which she spoke about the mental state her childhood had left her with. She said that sometimes she would watch Gone with the Wind and have a very emotional reaction.

In fact, she would often cry upon seeing Clark interact with his onscreen daughter. Sometimes, she said, “I pretend it’s me.”

An issue close to home

Judy passed away in 2011 at the age of 79, and she left behind one daughter: Maria Tinney Dagit. Obituaries for her pointed out that although she’d spent some time in showbusiness just like her father, she took on a different path.

A bit later in life, Judy earned degrees in clinical psychology and became a counselor who specialized in foster care and unwed moms.

The top of the field

Judy’s life was chaotic, but so was that of her half-brother and his family. John Clarke Gable was an object of interest as he grew up, as he was the son that his Hollywood superstar dad never got to meet.

He did an interview with People magazine in 1984, and said, “I’m very proud of the Gable name. My father was at the top of his field, and I want to be at the top of mine.”

A rough start

As it turned out, John attempted to follow in the footsteps of his father, and he appeared in a few movies from 1990 onwards. But he wasn’t anywhere near as successful, unfortunately.

And in 2013 he was arrested after crashing his pickup truck. Subsequently, John was charged with both a hit-and-run and driving under the influence.

Classically handsome

John’s son Clark Gable III seemed to have more success in showbusiness at first. From 2012 to 2013 he was the host of the reality television show Cheaters.

And he seemed to have inherited his grandfather’s famous good looks, as well – including the distinctive ears that once so frightened Loretta Young.

Run-ins with the law

But Clark III likewise had trouble with the law. In 2011 the lookalike grandson of the famous actor was arrested for the crime of pointing a laser inside a police helicopter.

He was charged with a felony and sentenced to ten days in prison, while two other felony counts were dropped in exchange for a guilty plea.

Explaining what happened

At the time, Clark III’s manager Roxane Davis told the CNN website. “Boys will be boys, and he was playing with what he thought was a toy and not a felony piece.

From what he told me from jail, he had it out the window, and he was shining it out the window, and the next thing he knew was that he had a spotlight on him.”

A deadly combination

And when Clark III sadly died, it was reported that drugs were involved. In April 2019 the celebrity gossip website TMZ announced that alprazolam, oxycodone, and fentanyl were found in the young man’s system.

Furthermore, the report indicated that “the medical examiner also found [that Clark] had a history of abusing weed, alcohol and Xanax.”

Worrying about Clark

TMZ sought out the people who had been working with Clark III on Cheaters. The creator of Cheaters, Bobby Goldstein, told TMZ that he had never seen him using drugs.

He added that he’d been reassured of that by the man himself. But the website also stated that crew members “worried about his drug use.”

Condolences

The Gable family was naturally devastated when Clark III passed. His mother Tracy Yarro Scheff posted on Instagram, “It is with an extremely heavy heart we say goodbye to my beautiful son Clark."

"He passed this morning. I will always be next to you my beautiful son. Mom.” And his sister Kayley wrote, “I’m so sorry we couldn’t save you…”

Loss too soon

After the untimely passing of her son, Tracy spoke to the Daily Mail newspaper about what had happened. She said of the youngest Clark Gable:

“Through the years he has struggled with addiction. I don’t know if that took his life, but I know that wasn’t what he wanted to do.”

His number one priority

Clark III had become a father not long before he died, Tracy said. He was the dad to a toddler called Shore. The grieving mother and grandmother said:

“When his girlfriend got pregnant, there was nothing more important for him than being there for the birth of his daughter. That’s all that mattered to him.”

A pattern emerges...

Now another child in the Gable family would grow up not knowing their father, as both John Gable II and Judy Lewis had done. Tracy said, “I saw a sweet boy who loved his little girl.”

She went on, “[Shore is] only one and a half, so I don’t know how much she’ll remember. But we have lots of video and photos.”

His dad's shocking response

Unfortunately, the tragic event put some unpleasant things in the spotlight with regards to the wider Gable family. After her brother’s death, Kayley posted some screenshotted text messages to Facebook.

Allegedly, they were from her father. And in the messages, John Clark Gable appeared to more or less disown his son in death.

The Facebook message

The message from John read, “I’m sorry for your loss. This is what I want. Cremate him; he’s not going in my family’s plot and I’m not paying for anything. All of you use my father’s name in disgrace...

"...and you don’t want me to go to the media, believe me. Leave me and my father out of this drug mess. There are no services on my end. Kayley is to never call me.”

Leaving the family behind

John too had struggled with drugs in the past, Tracy claimed in her Daily Mail interview. She said, “Addiction ruined our marriage. I wasn’t going to have it, so I took my kids."

"Clark was one and Kayley was three. I tried as much as I could to help John, but you can’t help them unless they want to help themselves. I wasn’t going to have any of it, so that’s when I left him.”

Addiction takes over

Tracy said that she hadn’t spoken to John for a long time, but of her son’s death she concluded, “I don’t blame anybody. I think addiction is nobody’s fault but the addict’s."

"It’s a disease, it takes over, and no matter how hard you want them to change the only person that has that power is them. They have to fight for it.”

Kayley fights back

But as a response to the text message from her father, Kayley expressed deep anger. She wrote on her Facebook page:

“I’m sorry, as my brother is in a coffin I’m standing up for him, as I always have, and the world needs to know the truth. I’m putting this out before you start telling lies. John f*** you!”

Waiting for the book

Kayley wrote on, “You’re the one who got us high on drugs and did drugs in front of us as kids and tortured us and especially Clark so I’m going to write a book and let the world know the truth!”

Maybe one day the book will materialize, but it’s clear even without it that the Gable family is in a heartbreaking situation.